The Battle of the Eyeliners: Wonderskin vs. Tarte vs. Glossier
Eyeliner is one of those makeup products that I’m super picky about. As a freelance makeup artist with 10 years of experience working on everything from TV and film sets to bridal and editorial looks, I’ve tried what feels like a million different eyeliners (my makeup drawer is a graveyard of half-used pens). Each eyeliner serves a unique purpose for the different looks I create, so I’ve finally narrowed it down to three contenders: Wonderskin’s 1440 Eyeliner, Tarte’s Double Take Eyeliner, and Glossier’s Pro Tip Eyeliner.
I’ve put these through it all – from busy days to late nights. So, if you want an eyeliner that can keep up, stick around as I break down which one takes the crown.
If you’re looking for an eyeliner that lasts… Wonderskin
When it comes to longevity, Wonderskin’s 1440 Eyeliner is the undefeated champ. I’m talking 24 hours of smudge-proof, waterproof magic. No midday touch-ups, no raccoon eyes, no fading. Whether it’s a long workday or a night out, Wonderskin stays flawless. Meanwhile, Tarte’s and Glossier’s look great at first, but you’ll need to reapply by happy hour.
Grab the Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner now with our exclusive offer: Buy 2, Get 1 Free! Explore different colors to match your vibe for every occasion!
If you want an intense color… Wonderskin
If you’re all about bold, rich colors, Wonderskin is the one. With just one swipe, the pigmentation is intense and doesn’t fade throughout the day. I love how creamy it feels, gliding on like butter and staying vibrant all day. Plus, you literally have 12 shades to choose from, so you can get really creative and try different colors for different vibes! Tarte gets close, especially with its liquid side, but you’ll need to layer it to get the same intensity. Glossier is more subtle and perfect for a softer look, but it won’t give you that dramatic eye-popping effect I like.
If you’re looking for easy, precise application… Tarte
When it comes to precision, Tarte’s Double Take truly shines! Its dual-ended design — liquid on one end and pencil on the other — allows for endless possibilities, whether you want bold wings or softer lines. Still, Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner comes in at a close second with its TruGlide Technology, which makes it feel silky-smooth and tug-free with every application. Glossier Pro Tip lags behind with its drier formula, which can make application a bit tricky.
If you want a vegan, cruelty-free option… All win
When it comes to being cruelty-free and vegan, Wonderskin, Tarte, and Glossier all lead the way. As a makeup artist, I prioritize ethical beauty choices for both myself and my clients. I love knowing that I can use any of these eyeliners while aligning with my values. This commitment to cruelty-free and vegan products isn’t just a trend; it’s a reflection of my dedication to promoting healthier choices in beauty. It’s essential for me to share these values, as I aim to ensure that my clients feel good about the products I use on their skin.
If you’re looking for the best bang for your buck… Wonderskin
When it comes to price and value, Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner takes the crown. At $18, it’s my favorite budget-friendly pick. Plus, the Buy 2, Get 1 Free deal brings the cost down to just $12 per liner! Tarte’s comes in at $25, which feels like more of a splurge, but you are getting two products in one, so there’s some added value there. Glossier Pro Tip is the cheapest at $16, but considering its shorter wear time and less intense color, you might find yourself replacing it more often.
My Final Pick: Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner
After testing all three, Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner comes out on top. While Tarte Double Take wins in the precision department and Glossier Pro Tip offers an affordable option, neither can match Wonderskin’s 24-hour wear, creamy texture, and rich pigment.
So, if you’re looking for an eyeliner that can keep up with whatever your day (or night) throws at you, Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner is the one you’ll want in your makeup bag. And with the chance to try out different colors through the Buy 2, Get 1 Free offer, there’s no better time to experiment with your looks!