I’m a Nurse Who Tried SkinnyFit and Vital Proteins—Here’s the Collagen That Actually Worked

In the overwhelming world of collagen supplements, finding one that actually works, tastes good, and fits seamlessly into a wellness routine isn’t easy. As a registered nurse—and someone who lives and breathes health and wellness, I’ve read every label, watched every influencer review, and scrolled deep into the comments sections trying to decode what’s hype and what’s actually helping people glow from the inside out.

After months of searching, I narrowed it down to two of the most talked-about options: SkinnyFit’s Super Youth and Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides Advanced. I tried both, and after testing them in my daily routine, I’ve got a clear winner.

Collagen Quality & Variety: SkinnyFit Wins

One of the biggest differentiators between these two is the type of collagen used. Vital Proteins’ Collagen Peptides Advanced gives you Types I and III—great for skin, hair, and nails, sure—but SkinnyFit’s Super Youth goes above and beyond, offering five types: I, II, III, V, and X. That means it supports not just skin, hair, and nails, but joints, digestion, and connective tissues, too.

As someone who’s active (hello, 12-hour nursing shifts and yoga in the mornings), having a supplement that supports my whole body—not just my complexion—is a huge win.

Value for Money: Tie (but SkinnyFit Offers More)

There’s no denying it: Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides Advanced is more affordable, coming in at $25.49 compared to SkinnyFit’s Super Youth at $59.97. On price alone, Vital Proteins seems like the budget-friendly option.

But here’s where that number starts to feel a little misleading.

With SkinnyFit, you’re not just getting collagen—you’re getting a comprehensive, multi-benefit supplement. It includes:

• 5 types of collagen
• 13-strain probiotic blend
• Apple cider vinegar
• Organic Baobab Fiber
• Hyaluronic acid
• Vitamin C

In other words, you’d need to buy multiple supplements to get what’s packed into a single scoop of Super Youth. When I factor in how much I’d spend on separate gut health, skin support, and collagen boosters? SkinnyFit actually saves me money in the long run and simplifies my wellness routine.

If you’re just dipping your toe into collagen and want a super basic option, Vital Proteins might do the trick. But if you’re looking for a total beauty and wellness formula that delivers visible results, SkinnyFit is worth every penny.

Results & Benefits: SkinnyFit Shines

After a month of Vital Proteins, I noticed slightly stronger nails, but the impact was minimal. With SkinnyFit, the changes were more dramatic. My hair feels thicker, my skin is dewier and more even, and my nails have stopped peeling. I’ve even noticed less post-workout joint stiffness, which I didn’t expect, but fully welcome.

It made losing those last few pounds a breeze, and my clothes fit so much better. I genuinely feel better and look better—which is exactly what I hoped collagen would do.

Flavor & Drinkability: SkinnyFit Takes It Again

Vital Proteins has a “neutral” flavor, which is code for: you better mix it into something, because on its own, it’s gross. I tried it in coffee and smoothies, and while it wasn’t offensive, it just didn’t add anything either.

SkinnyFit, on the other hand, offers multiple flavors, ranging from unflavored to chocolate to peach mango. I tried the strawberry watermelon flavor, and it has become a highlight of my day. I actually look forward to mixing it into water in the morning or after my workout. It makes staying consistent easy—and the best supplement is the one you’ll actually take.

The Final Verdict: SkinnyFit is the Clear Winner

If you’re looking for a multi-collagen supplement that’s delicious, effective, and jam-packed with wellness benefits, SkinnyFit’s Super Youth is the one. As a nurse, I’m picky about what I put into my body. As a woman in my 30s, I’m equally picky about what’s helping me feel and look my best.

SkinnyFit checks every box—and then some. It’s a supplement I genuinely enjoy using, and the results speak for themselves.

So if you’re collagen-curious or ready to level up your current routine, take it from someone who’s done the homework: SkinnyFit’s Super Youth is worth every scoop.